By Emily Harrison
Millions of people start each year, each Monday, or each health scare with the same four letters: SMART. Write a goal, run it through the checklist, watch it fail anyway. This is not a coincidence, and it is not a personal failing. The SMART framework was built for a very different job than the one health behaviors ask it to do.
George Doran introduced the acronym in a November 1981 issue of Management Review, in a short article titled “There’s a S.M.A.R.T. way to write management’s goals and objectives.” Doran was writing for corporate managers who needed to translate department objectives into something a supervisor could evaluate at the end of a quarter. His original five letters were Specific, Measurable, Assignable, Realistic, and Time-related. Later versions swapped in Achievable and Relevant, and the framework spread far beyond the office memo it was born in, eventually landing in gyms, weight-loss apps, therapy worksheets, and New Year’s resolution lists.
That spread is understandable. SMART is easy to teach, easy to remember, and easy to turn into a worksheet. Nurses use it to write care plans, personal trainers use it to open a first session, and countless January 1 journal entries start with a version of it scribbled in the margin. Search interest in the phrase spikes every year in the first two weeks of January and drops just as fast by February, which tracks with survey data on resolution abandonment: a large share of people who set a health-related resolution report giving up within roughly a month.
But a framework built to help a regional sales manager report quarterly numbers to a supervisor carries assumptions that do not hold up well against a body that gets sick, a schedule that changes without warning, or a habit that has to survive a bad week and not just a good one. A manager’s objective lives inside a controlled system: a fixed budget, a known team, a quarter with a clear start and end date. A health behavior lives inside a body that sleeps poorly some nights, a calendar that gets rearranged by other people, and a motivation level that shifts for reasons that have nothing to do with willpower. This article looks at why the framework struggles specifically with health behaviors, and at what tends to work better once the checklist stops helping.
What “SMART” Actually Meant in 1981
Doran’s original piece is worth reading closely because the popular version of SMART has drifted from it. Doran was not proposing a universal theory of motivation. He was offering a practical writing aid for managers who tended to submit objectives that were too vague to evaluate. “Assignable” meant a named person was responsible for the outcome, not that the goal was reachable. “Realistic” referred to whether the organization had the resources to pursue the objective, not whether the individual felt confident about hitting it.
Doran also included a caveat that rarely survives the retelling: he wrote that it isn’t necessary for every objective to meet all five criteria, and that some abstract, less measurable goals still deserve a place alongside the concrete ones. The rigid, all-five-boxes-checked version of SMART that shows up in modern coaching materials is stricter than what Doran actually proposed.
None of this means SMART is worthless. Locke and Latham’s goal-setting research, built from roughly 400 laboratory and field studies over more than two decades, consistently found that specific, challenging goals outperform vague ones like “do your best” in workplace and task-performance settings. A classic example from that body of work involved high school students doing sit-up tests: those given a specific, challenging target outperformed peers given a vague instruction to improve. That is a real and well-replicated finding. The trouble starts when a framework validated mostly in structured, short-duration performance tasks gets applied wholesale to something as long, messy, and biologically variable as changing how a person eats, moves, or sleeps.
Three Ways the Framework Breaks Down for Health Behaviors
Rigid Specificity Collides With the Variability of Real Life
A specific goal like “run 5 kilometers four times a week” is easy to write and easy to evaluate. It is also brittle. A cold, a work deadline, a child’s fever, or a sore knee does not care that the plan said four times. Health behaviors unfold inside a body and a life that both fluctuate week to week, and a goal with no room for that fluctuation tends to produce one of two outcomes: the person forces the plan through a week when their body needed rest, or they miss a session and experience the miss as evidence the plan, and sometimes they, have failed.
Contrast that with performance goals in a controlled workplace task, where conditions are relatively stable and the person is not also managing sleep debt, appetite, hormonal cycles, or a household. Specificity is a strength when the environment is predictable. It becomes a liability when the environment is a human life.
The “Achievable” Trap: Aiming Low to Avoid Failure
“Achievable” sounds like sensible advice, but in practice it often nudges people toward the smallest goal they can defend rather than the goal that would actually change their health trajectory. Because the SMART checklist rewards a goal for being checkable and low-risk, people learn to write goals they are almost certain to hit: “walk 10 minutes twice a week” instead of building an actual movement habit, or “drink one more glass of water a day” instead of addressing why hydration slipped in the first place.
This is the opposite of what Locke and Latham’s own research on goal difficulty found in performance settings, where specific, difficult goals set near the upper range of what a person could plausibly achieve produced better results than easy goals. Health coaching culture absorbed the “achievable” letter but often lost the “difficult, and still credible” half of the original research, leaving a watered-down goal that is technically SMART and practically inert.
Time-Bound Pressure and All-or-Nothing Failure
The “time-bound” letter forces a deadline onto behaviors that do not actually resolve on a deadline. Fitness, sleep quality, and eating patterns are ongoing processes, not projects with a finish line. When a goal like “lose 10 pounds in 8 weeks” hits its deadline and the number on the scale falls short, the standard response is to treat the entire effort as a failure, even if the person built genuinely useful habits along the way.
This pattern echoes what addiction researchers Alan Marlatt and Judith Gordon described in the 1980s as the abstinence violation effect: a single lapse, interpreted through an all-or-nothing lens, triggers a much larger collapse in effort than the lapse itself would justify. A missed workout becomes a missed week. One dessert becomes a scrapped diet. The deadline built into a SMART goal, rather than motivating a strong finish, often manufactures the exact moment where dichotomous thinking takes over and the behavior gets abandoned altogether.
Quick Snapshot: Where the Letters Strain
- S — Specific: Assumes a stable routine; health behaviors operate inside a variable body and schedule.
- M — Measurable: Rewards what is easy to count (steps, pounds) over what actually matters (energy, consistency, sleep quality).
- A — Achievable: Often gets interpreted as “safe,” which pulls goals toward the smallest defensible target.
- R — Relevant: Rarely questioned in practice, even though the wrong health goal can be perfectly relevant and still miss the underlying problem.
- T — Time-bound: Imposes a deadline on an ongoing process, setting up an all-or-nothing verdict.
The Measurable Trap: When Numbers Hide the Real Progress
“Measurable” sounds neutral, but it quietly decides which parts of a health behavior get to count. A number on a scale is easy to measure. Sleep quality, energy across the afternoon, mood stability, or how a person’s clothes fit are harder to reduce to a single figure, so they tend to drop out of the goal entirely in favor of whatever is simplest to track. The result is a goal that measures the wrong thing well rather than the right thing loosely.
This matters because the measurable variable is not always the variable that is changing. Someone building a strength-training habit might gain muscle while their body weight stays flat or even rises slightly, and a goal fixated on a bathroom scale will read that as failure even though the underlying behavior is working. A goal built entirely around what is convenient to count can end up rewarding the wrong signal and hiding the actual progress underneath it.
The SMART Critique at a Glance
| SMART Component | Intended Purpose (1981) | Common Friction in Health Behaviors |
|---|---|---|
| Specific | Clarify what a manager should report on | Leaves no room for illness, fatigue, or a packed week |
| Measurable | Give a supervisor a number to check | Favors easy-to-count outcomes over the process behind them |
| Achievable | Match objectives to available resources | Encourages small, low-risk targets that don’t move the needle |
| Relevant | Tie the goal to a broader business aim | Rarely challenged, so a mismatched goal can still pass the checklist |
| Time-bound | Set a reporting deadline for a manager | Turns an ongoing habit into a pass/fail event |
What Works Better for Health Behavior Change
None of this means people should abandon structure altogether. It means the structure needs to fit the terrain. Three approaches, drawn from behavioral science rather than management theory, tend to hold up better over months and years.
Flexible Systems Instead of Fixed Targets
A system describes what a person does regularly and adjusts as conditions change, rather than a single number they either hit or miss. “I move my body most days, and I scale the intensity to how I slept” survives a bad week in a way that “run 20 miles a week” does not. Systems absorb variability instead of breaking against it, because the definition of success shifts from a fixed outcome to a repeated behavior.
A practical way to build one is to define a minimum, a target, and a stretch version of the same behavior ahead of time, rather than deciding in the moment. A walking system might set 10 minutes as the minimum on a rough day, 30 minutes as the standard target, and 60 minutes as the stretch version on a day with extra time and energy. Every one of those counts as a win, which keeps the habit alive through the low-energy weeks that a single fixed target would simply record as missed.
Process Goals Over Outcome Goals
Outcome goals describe a result (a body weight, a resting heart rate, a race time). Process goals describe an action fully within a person’s control (preparing lunch the night before, walking after dinner, going to bed at a consistent time). Outcomes are influenced by genetics, hormones, sleep, stress, and dozens of variables outside anyone’s direct control, so tying success entirely to an outcome sets people up for a verdict they cannot fully steer. Process goals keep the scoreboard on the behavior itself, which is both more motivating day to day and a better predictor of the outcome eventually showing up.
This distinction also changes how a missed day gets interpreted. Missing an outcome target, such as a weekly weigh-in, delivers no information about what to change tomorrow. Missing a process target, such as skipping the planned after-dinner walk, points directly at the behavior to adjust: move it earlier, pair it with a phone call to a friend, or shorten it on nights that run long. The process goal fails in a way that teaches something, while the outcome goal usually just fails.
Implementation Intentions: The “If-Then” Plan
Psychologist Peter Gollwitzer’s research on implementation intentions offers one of the more consistent, well-replicated tools in this space. Instead of a general intention (“I’ll eat better”), an implementation intention names the exact cue and the exact response: “If it is 6 p.m. and I’m leaving work, then I will drive straight to the gym before going home.” Research using this format has produced striking results in health settings. In one study on breast self-examination, women who formed a specific if-then plan completed the exam at a 100 percent rate over the following month, compared with 53 percent among women who only had a general intention to do it. In a weight-loss study, participants who used implementation intentions lost an average of 4.2 kilograms over two months, compared with 2.1 kilograms for those who attended standard group meetings without the added planning step. Because goal intentions alone account for only an estimated 20 to 30 percent of the variance in whether people actually follow through, closing that gap with a concrete cue matters more than refining the goal statement itself.
We go deeper on structuring these day-to-day cues in our companion guide to habit stacking strategies for turning routines into lasting change, and on shifting the scoreboard away from outcomes in our piece on process goals versus outcome goals.
A Simpler Alternative: The “Flexible Four”
Instead of forcing a health behavior through all five SMART letters, try asking four looser questions: What’s the smallest version of this I can do on a bad day? What is the specific cue that will trigger it? How will I know I’m building the habit, not just hoping for one? And what will I do the day after I miss it? That last question, largely absent from SMART, is often the one that determines whether a lapse turns into a pattern or stays a single missed day.
Putting It Together: A More Realistic Approach to Health Goals
None of this requires throwing out structure or measurement. It requires putting the right kind of structure around a health behavior instead of the kind built for a quarterly business review. A useful health goal usually keeps some DNA from SMART, a clear direction and some way to track progress, while trading the rigid deadline for an ongoing system, trading the vague “achievable” instinct for a genuinely challenging but sustainable target, and trading the single specific action for a cued, if-then plan that can flex around a bad night’s sleep or a packed calendar.
Someone trying to build a walking habit, for instance, might keep a form of specificity (walking after dinner, most days) and a form of measurability (a weekly minimum rather than a daily mandate), while dropping the hard deadline in favor of an open-ended system that keeps running past week eight, past the goal being “achieved,” and into an actual habit. The letters aren’t the enemy. The rigidity that crept into how they get applied is.
Consider two people trying to build the same habit of eating more vegetables. The first writes a SMART goal: “Eat five servings of vegetables daily for the next 30 days.” Week one goes fine. Week three includes a work trip, and the goal breaks the first night the hotel restaurant has nothing but a side salad. By week four, the entire effort is abandoned as a failed 30-day plan. The second person sets a process goal with a built-in floor: “I add a vegetable to at least one meal most days, and I treat travel days as a pause, not a reset.” The habit trip does not end the streak, because there was never a streak to break, only a repeated behavior that resumes as soon as conditions allow. Eighteen months later, one of these two people still has the habit. It is rarely the one who wrote the more precise-sounding goal.
Conclusion
SMART goals were never designed to hold up a human body through a full year of illness, travel, stress, and shifting motivation. They were designed to help a manager write a clearer memo. That mismatch, not any flaw in the individual trying to use the framework, explains a great deal of why so many health goals stall out. Swapping rigid deadlines for flexible systems, outcome targets for process goals, and vague intentions for specific if-then cues gives health behaviors the kind of structure they can actually survive on.
Frequently Asked Questions
Are SMART goals completely useless for health and fitness?
No. The core idea of stating a clear, trackable goal instead of a vague wish still has value. The problem is treating all five letters as mandatory and rigid rather than as a loose starting point, and losing the “time-bound” deadline mindset that turns an ongoing habit into a pass/fail event.
Why do so many New Year’s resolutions written as SMART goals fail by February?
Resolutions often combine an aggressive outcome target with a hard external deadline and little room for a bad week. Once one deadline-linked goal is missed, all-or-nothing thinking, the same pattern researchers have documented in relapse after a single lapse, tends to end the effort altogether rather than adjusting the plan.
What should I use instead of a SMART goal for something like weight loss or fitness?
Pair a process goal you fully control, such as preparing three dinners at home each week, with an if-then implementation intention that names the exact trigger and action. Track the behavior itself rather than only the outcome, since the outcome is affected by many factors outside your control.
What is an implementation intention, in plain terms?
It’s a specific “if this, then that” plan that links a concrete situation to a concrete action, for example, “If I finish my lunch break, then I will take a 10-minute walk.” Research by Peter Gollwitzer and others has repeatedly found this format outperforms general intentions across health behaviors.
Did George Doran, who created SMART, intend for it to be used this rigidly?
Not quite. Doran’s 1981 article noted that not every objective needs to satisfy all five criteria, and that some abstract goals still belong alongside the concrete, measurable ones. The strict, every-letter-required version common in coaching materials today is stricter than his original proposal.
Can SMART goals and flexible systems be combined?
Yes. Many people keep a general direction and a way of tracking progress from the SMART approach while replacing the hard deadline with an ongoing system and replacing a single specific target with a cued if-then plan that can flex around real life.
References
- Doran, G. T. (1981). “There’s a S.M.A.R.T. way to write management’s goals and objectives.” Management Review, 70(11), 35-36.
- Locke, E. A., & Latham, G. P. (2002). Building a practically useful theory of goal setting and task motivation. American Psychologist, 57(9), 705-717.
- Gollwitzer, P. M. (1999). Implementation intentions: Strong effects of simple plans. American Psychologist, 54(7), 493-503.
- Sheeran, P. (2002). Intention-behavior relations: A conceptual and empirical review. European Review of Social Psychology, 12(1), 1-36.
- Marlatt, G. A., & Gordon, J. R. (1985). Relapse Prevention: Maintenance Strategies in the Treatment of Addictive Behaviors. Guilford Press.
- Orbell, S., Hodgkins, S., & Sheeran, P. (1997). Implementation intentions and the theory of planned behaviour. Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin, 23(9), 945-954.




















